Stephanie Char

I am an Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science at Williams College. My research interests span economic and military coercion, international institutions, and human rights. I study China’s foreign relations, with regional expertise in East and Southeast Asia. My dissertation was awarded the Nuno P. Monteiro Best Dissertation Award from the American Political Science Association’s International Relations Theory Section.

I was previously a postdoctoral fellow at the Columbia-Harvard China and the World Program and Weatherhead East Asian Institute at Columbia University and a Hans J. Morgenthau Fellow at the Notre Dame International Security Center. My research has been funded by Columbia University’s Weatherhead East Asian Institute, Institute for Social and Economic Research and Policy, and Columbia Experimental Laboratory in the Social Sciences. I received my Ph.D. in Political Science at Columbia University and B.A. from the School of Public and International Affairs at Princeton University. You can view my CV here and reach me at sc51@williams.edu.

Research

Dissertation

Scaring the Monkey by Killing the Chicken: Effectiveness of Countercriticism Coercion by China

In response to the 2010 Nobel Peace Prize to activist Liu Xiaobo, China restricted salmon imports from Norway and froze diplomatic relations with Norway for six years. This is an instance of countercriticism coercion, or threats and diplomatic and economic sanctions in response to purely rhetorical expressions of disapproval from other countries. Why do states ever respond coercively to human rights criticism from abroad, and what are the consequences of countercriticism coercion?

Economically powerful states that censor domestic speech are more likely to engage in countercriticism coercion. There have been over 80 instances of countercriticism coercion in response to United Nations country resolutions, prizes and meetings with human rights activists, and recognition of historical human rights atrocities since 1945. China is the predominant user of countercriticism coercion, followed by Turkey, and joined more recently by Saudi Arabia and India. China could enact countercriticism coercion to influence China’s domestic public, the direct target of coercion, or third-party states. China implements countercriticism coercion tacitly, rather than advertising coercive responses to the domestic public. Of all of China’s human rights critics, China overwhelmingly chooses to sanction champion states, which actively promote human rights principles abroad. Champion states that are the direct targets of countercriticism coercion, such as Norway, do not withdraw or suspend their human rights criticism of China. China’s tacitness and selection of targets suggests that China intends to deter third-party states from human rights criticism, using the logic of the Chinese phrase, “kill the chicken to scare the monkey.”

Countercriticism coercion has been effective at deterring third-party states from issuing human rights criticism. States with reputations for countercriticism coercion were less likely than states without reputations for countercriticism coercion to receive human rights criticism from other countries, accounting for other drivers of human rights criticism. In case studies of Indonesia and Malaysia, policymakers refrained from criticizing China over the situation in Xinjiang in 2019-22, while simultaneously criticizing other states that lacked reputations for countercriticism coercion. Policymakers observed China’s past behavior in response to human rights criticism and withheld criticism to avert economic retaliation. Among third-party states, states with higher potential economic gains from China’s Belt and Road Initiative, measured through states’ infrastructure deficiencies, were more likely to be deterred from criticizing China. In comparison to China, Saudi Arabia has similarly failed to influence the direct targets and has been less effective than China at deterring third-party states, but may carry out countercriticism coercion to influence its domestic public.

This study demonstrates that developing a reputation for economic coercion can be effective at influencing third-party states. China’s more assertive foreign policy may have undermined China’s relations with the targets of coercion, but has deterred a broader audience of third-party states from publicly criticizing China. The continued effectiveness of countercriticism coercion could undermine the international human rights order by reducing criticism of powerful states with reputations for countercriticism coercion.

Publications

“Hypocrisy Claims: Women's Voices and the Erosion of Women's Rights in Autocracies” with Lisa Fan

Forthcoming, Comparative Political Studies

Authoritarian regimes routinely restrict women's rights while claiming to champion them. How do regime subordinates navigate public backlash when the government undermines the very rights it claims to advance? We identify hypocrisy claims - accusations that the opposition violates standards it professes to uphold - as one rhetorical strategy. We theorize that regime subordinates intensify hypocrisy claims following rollbacks in women's rights, with women drawing on their gendered authority to deliver these claims. Using natural language processing on Turkish parliamentary speeches (2015-2023), we find hypocrisy claims significantly increased after Turkey's 2021 Istanbul Convention withdrawal and 2016 Marriage Bill, with no comparable increase following controversial rhetoric or crises unrelated to women's rights. Regime women disproportionately drive this shift relative to regime men, with the effect concentrated among junior women. These findings reveal how hypocrisy claims operate following restrictions on women's rights, with regime women's voices at the forefront of this response.

Working Papers

“Silence on Human Rights: Economic Coercion and Deterrence from Criticism” (Under Review)

“Diminishing Multilateral Human Rights Criticism: Why China Sanctions Foreign Critics”

Works In Progress

“Peer Pressure: Interstate Criticism and Human Rights Treaty Ratification” with Lisa Fan

“Norm Proprietorship: China’s Global Advocacy” with Rachel Hulvey

“Competing for Influence through Regional Institutions: Evidence from the Mekong” with Nora Toh

Teaching

Columbia University

Economic Statecraft and China (2025) - Instructor of Record

Conceptual Foundations of International Politics (2021) - Cordier Fellow for Lisa Anderson

China’s Foreign Relations (2020, 2021, 2022) - Teaching Assistant for Tom Christensen

War, Peace, and Strategy (2019, 2020) - Teaching Assistant for Richard Betts